Convert To Editable Text - Colour Problem

I'm creating video transitions between DVD/BD menus. I've used Photoshop CS6 to design the menus.

I wanted to use an text animation preset for the text. To do so, I must selected the layer/layer Styles/convert to editable styles and then layer/convert to editable text before I can use the text preset.

This is where the problem happens. When applying the layer/convert to editable text. It makes the layer style lighter. This is very distracting when you press a button on the DVD/BD menu and the text changes colour when the animation is playing then changes back to the original colour on the menu.

I've compared the style settings in After Effects against the Photoshop styles and they have the same settings.

How can I stop this from happening?